Description

You're looking at a different kind of "All Out Assault", this one based on utilizing a fuller expression of current excellent technology, as opposed to a limited expression of such. Some go for a cost-no-object expression of one technology. I have chosen to pursue a superb expression of different technologies. I have derived far more pleasure doing so than seeking one rig to satisfy my longings to hear beautiful systems. 

Photos represent some of the speakers, components and cables I have reviewed over the years. I have spent time predominantly with four technologies in speakers; Full range hybrid dyanamic, Full range ESL, and Omnidirectional hybrid. I have branched out to horn hybrid as well. 

I have moved to file and streaming playback exclusively utilizing Tidal and ROON. However, I maintain CD as backup source. I find a shocking disparity in performance of digital based systems. 

This is a dedicated room, built by myself and tuned for two channel, but wired for 7.1 surround. I listen to 2 ch. audio approx. 95-98% of time. The surround and video compliment is not noteworthy, as a result. I upgrade them only every several years. 

Source, amplification and speakers have all been reviewed and are highly recommended. The sound quality of the system is moving steadily toward SOTA.

System listing updated September, 2022
Read more...

Room Details

Dimensions: 23’ × 13’  Medium
Ceiling: 7’


Components Toggle details

    • Aspen Acoustics Grand Aspen Speaker
    Continuing development of Scott Kindt's DLT (Disproportionately Large Tweeter; my term) designs. The Grand Aspen is the new flagship, extension of the Capella (previously called the Lagrange L5 MkII, seen below). 

    The Grand Aspen is a six-way speaker with built in active, oppositional, slot loaded subwoofer. I will be giving this speaker an owner's review to appear at Dagogo.com
    • Legacy Audio Whisper DSW Clarity Edition
    Bill Dudleston realized my concept of a fully configurable speaker able to be employed as both passive and active. The result is what I call a "crossover speaker," which can be configured; 1. Fully passive, with as little as one stereo amp and three sets of speaker cables; 2. Hybrid active/passive, using the Legacy processor for the bass and the Mid/Treble passive, and 3: Fully active, using six channels of outboard amplification. 

    The speaker has been retrofitted for a review of upgrade internal cabling and capacitors. The result is the Whisper DSW, which Bill Dudleston of Legacy measured a 2 dB improvement on the Bass! 
    • PureAudioProject Trio15 PAP Horn 1
    Wonderful two-way hybrid horn reviewed for Dagogo.com. I enjoy the flexibility of the speaker in the crossover and "internal" wiring. My special utilization of the speaker is in Landscape mode, the realization of a dream for an alternative sound which I have pursued for about five years. The Horn 1 in Landscape impressed the entire audio group of which I am a member; they all placed it among the very best systems I have made. It truly is a stunning application of an affordable speaker with high end sensibility.
    • PureAudioProject Trio15 Horn 1 Landscape Orientation
    Alternative application of using Sound Anchor custom stands to hold speakers sideways. This results in a far wider soundstage superlative for live music recordings. Note that the orientation of the horn of the Horn 1 speaker is normally horizontal, so the Landscape mode/application results in the speaker's horn turned vertical, similar to large horn speakers such as the Volti Audio Alura.
    • PureAudioProject Quintet15 Horn1
    Largest of PureAudioProject (PAP) offerings, this one outfitted with the horn driver. Features upgradable crossover components (cap, resistor) and "internal" wiring. 

    This speaker is especially beautiful sounding with the Legacy Audio i.V4 Ultra Amplifier. Both products reviewed for Dagogo.com 
    • King Sound King III
    The King III is a full range ESL with a performance which takes back seat to no magnetic planar speakers. With subwoofers they are a formidable ESL experience.
    • Aspen Acoustics Capella Speaker
    Craft speaker made by a Colorado physics teacher. This is the pre-production model. Uses what I term the unique DLT (Disproportionately Large Tweeter) configuration. It has the punch of a dynamic speaker with the generosity of a panel speaker. 

    A more formidable model, the Grand Aspen, is under construction and will be replacing the pair of Capella speakers in my possession. The Grand Aspen features an enhanced DLT array, as seen on the Aspen Acoustics website. 

    See review of smaller model, L5 MkII at Dagogo.com 
    • Kings Audio Kingsound King Tower
    Omnidirectional hybrid dynamic/ribbon speaker system not available in N. America. and perhaps entirely disconintued by Kings Audio. Added to my collection as an expression of Omnidirectional speaker technology.
    • Perlisten D212s Subwoofers
    Pair of Perlisten Audio D212s Subwoofers as reviewed by myself for Dagogo.com 

    I enjoyed the Legacy Audio XTREME XD Subs for ten years. Perlisten incorporates room correction in the subs, allowing me to maximize different genres of speakers used in reviewing. These are impressive devices. 
    • Exogal Comet DAC and Ion PowerDAC
    This is an unusual combination of a DAC (Comet) with an additional complementary extended DAC with integrated true digital amp (Ion). Together, they include everything needed in the front end of a system except for the source. The Comet can stand alone, but the Ion is dependent upon the Comet, it cannot be used separately. 

    This combination is thrilling in its performance to cost ratio. One of the most outstanding products I have reviewed in ten years! The digital amplification is especially notable for its ability at 100wpc to drive more difficult speakers to listening levels of about 88-90dB. 
    • Eastern Electric Minimax DSD DAC Supreme
    Latest EE DAC featuring DSD and continues to offer opportunity to roll in discrete opamps. Allows contouring system to any selection of components.
    • Discrete Opamps Staccato, Burson, Sonic Imagery, Sparkos Lab
    Discrete opamps rolled into Eastern Electric Minimax DACs and Kinki Studio EX-M1+ Integrated Amplifier
    • Iconoclast Cables and BAV Power Cords Iconoclast/Belden
    Current reference cable line. See review at Dagogo.com
    • Owned/Reviewed Spkr Cables Various
    Have owned: Audioquest, Harmonic Technology, XLO, etc; Reviewed cables for Dagogo.com include: Iconoclast, TEO Audio, Clarity Cable, Silnote Audio, Snake River Audio,  Wire World. etc.
    • Outlaw 950 Surround Processor
    Has nice variety of surround settings, 2 component in, plenty of other inputs... Only thing I wished it did was to convert s video to component.
    • Rotel RB-976
    A lovely little workhorse amp! Configurable from 3-6 channels; a wonderful flexibility for surround applications.
    • Magnepan MGM W
    Very affordable planars for surround. They only play down to about 100khz, but acceptable for surround. Awesome feature - they can be mounted upside down (will sound the same) to accomodate wiring near top of room.
    • Legacy Audio Silver Screen
    Black piano finish; complementary driver set to Focus HD; dual 7" bass, 4" planar mid, 1" tweet
    • Tice Audio Solo/Solo High Current
    I'm using two Solos, and one is High Current for power amps. Gotta have someting like this to open up the system's sound...but price might be a bit steep for some people. I will accept an offer of $1,000,000.00 though.
    • Furutech GTX-D (G)
    Audiophile grade outlet featuring copper internals and gold plated sockets for power cord pins
    • Plateau AV 42
    Wonderfully solid, black for AV use. Affordable. Nice to have on casters when you have to move it.
    • Panasonic PTL-500U
    Upgrade from PTL-330U; this unit has high def capabilities.
    • Auralex Propannel 2x4'
    Room tuning sound absorbing pannels. Made a shockingly huge difference in my two channel listening! Some of best audio $ I ever spent!

Comments 397

Doug,
I am sure the TEO Lquid Pre is special. I did contact them about a balanced version but was told it will take a major reworking of the preamp, and they do not have time presently for that. I also enquired about an additional output (which is common with most preamps) but was told I have to purchase 10 Liquid Pre's in order for that to materialise.

4orreal

Owner
System edited: Putting up some beautiful systems lately with the TEO Audio Liquid Pre. I had a seasoned audiophile who runs SET/HE and vinyl, as well as an industry insider here lately. Both enthusiastically endorsed the rig as the best I have assembled. I'm quite pleased with the combination of the TEO Liquid Pre and Wells Audio Innamorata amp.

douglas_schroeder

Owner
Eugene, It's fun watching you remake your system and experience the thrill of a massive upgrade. We tend to think the current sound is pretty close to state of the art, but there are literally hundreds of levels of sound quality and always a lot of room for improvement.

Make sure you demo the TEO Audio Liquid cable interconnects.

USB cable is crucial to top end sound for file playback; it can make or break the entire system's sound. Then again, I've often said that every link, from power cord to speaker is crucial.

I do have many "just sit there and listen moments," as you said, and they are precious. But at heart I am a system builder, and find joy in exploration of systems as much as anything. That's why I love having more than one type of speaker technology and the opportunity of discrete opamp rolling a DAC. Both yield endless fun and new experiences. :) You will be able to get much of the same flexibility and new experiences through USB cables.

I'm looking forward to the massive upgrade in sound quality over the Nimbus White which the Joule White will represent. You have just gotten the new speaker, and if you continue to work with it you will be stunned how differently it will sound in six to twelve months! It has a lot more to give than you are hearing now. :)

douglas_schroeder

Owner
System edited: Did some picture updating, now showing the incredible TEO Audio Liquid Pre, a world-class caliber preamp. You will see in the pic that I am conducting tests on isolation. This is the only component I have used in the digital domain for which isolation has proven to be efficacious. I have been doing no streaming with the Sonos lately, as I can't get a WiFi signal into my bunker-like room through Apple products. I will be rearranging the home office to put it closer to the audio room beneath, so I hope that will fix the WiFi issue. Then I can push the boundaries of Sonos further. I have a custom build of the Vapor Audio Joule White coming soon. Combined with the Liquid Pre and Wells Innamorata amp it should push the performance to a new standard.

douglas_schroeder

Sounds like you are getting closer and closer to that satisfying just sit there and listen moment... I'm pretty happy now but still attempting to improve things... I might move to Antipodes DX top level server. The upgraded Cirrus to Joule with Dueland RS caps has amazing musical presentation, the mid and is off the charts, I just upgraded my PS Audio DSD DAC to their Pikes Peak release, added some Akiko tuning sticks and their triple ac stick, also I live around the corner from Mike Powell who owns Verastarr cable and use his a mix of his copper and all silver ac cables. He also has allowed me to test his new USB cable. I wholeheartedly agree with you I had formerly used an IFI cable and a Cardas cable, the Verastarr has made a considerable difference. Next I am going to try one of Audioquest Ethernet cables

eugene2

Owner
System edited: It's been a while since I updated my system. I have moved completely to file playback, with a Mac Mini controlled by iPad, a sensational world-class preamp in the TEO Audio Liquid Pre, continued discrete opamp rolling on Eastern Electric DACs, and have laid plans to secure a custom tricked out version of the Vapor Audio Joule White. The system has taken a decidedly SOTA turn in the past year, and file playback has been instrumental in it. USB cables have been essential, and a test between about eight products has found the Clarity Cable Organic USB to find consistent use in my rig. The Landscape orientation experiment was considered successful, but to extend other elements, i.e. TEO Audio Liquid Pre, I let go of the Daedalus Ulysses speakers. I have some other ideas in mind for further Landscape experiments. I am also summoning the courage to delve into a DIY build of Hypex nCore amps.

douglas_schroeder

Owner
Eugene2, I'm certainly not opposed to dedicated servers. I would anticipate that over time I will explore them thoroughly. Knowing that it's a big digital world out there for file playback, with a lot of moving pieces (companies, systems, etc.), when our household switched to Mac I thought it a lovely time to start simple with the Mac Mini. I had read all about the tweaks to the Mini, as well as the "opposition" PC file playback crowd.

Seeing how Mac is upgrading their Mini to have 32 bit ouput, which mine does, I'm happy I didn't go for an older unit and spend big on external PSU, etc. Macintosh upgrades their operating software's audio and I get an upgrade, too. And with the myriad of small servers out there, I'm not too worried that Mac will be out of business anytime soon. These are not minor considerations.

I thought it would be nice to start basic and see just how far I could get with a scratch computer, i.e. stock, and simultaneously entertain a theory that with the right DAC one might be able to replicate much of what a fancy dedicated server could do.

Right or wrong, I have made astounding strides in the sound quality of the humble Mac Mini. This is not to say that it's proven to be equal or better than a server, but it's surpassed where I thought it could get to. It's demonstrated to me that the selection of DAC, USB cable, interconnects and power cord in the file playback chain is profoundly important.

I figure in this year I will begin to work with some servers, and frankly I'm going to be disgusted if the sound quality is not radically better, for all the discussion about it being superior. The result I'm getting has surprised some veteran audiophiles who have heard my rig. I don't think they figured this kind of sound was possible from a humble file playback source.

I have an industry insider coming to my home this weekend, and I'm looking forward to having him hear the rig, as he heard it years ago and it's much more marvelous now than when I was spinning discs. He has a blown out dual computer setup with special software to optimize the playback. So, I think it will be very interesting to hear his comments. I'm hoping that the computer guru who set his system up will tag along as he may be able to come as well. Then I may get some very knowledgeable input as to where in general my efforts have gotten me.

Do I think I'm at the top of file playback? No, but neither do I think a file playback computer is an assurance that one will get optimum sound quality. I have heard systems with all manner of software, reclocking, power conditioning, etc. and I believe that I have already matched that level of definition and transparency, so what does that say?

To me it says the "K.I.S.S." method is working pretty good so far. But, I have also learned well enough that simply because the sound is great to my ears, it in no way means there is not a lot of gain to be had in improvements. I would love if at the end of this year I can look back and scoff at the sound quality I have now by moving to a custom server. :)

One of the people who will hear this rig eventually is Ryan at Vapor. He thought the Nimbus White sounded pretty good when they were first set up, but things have gotten far better.

douglas_schroeder

What about dedicated music server instead of the Mac mini, Ryan, Mike from Verastarr and I all have an Antipodes it has worked magically in my system.

eugene2

Doug...amazing review as always, very enjoyable reading!

zephyr24069

Owner
I just posted some impressions of the TEO Audio Liquid Pre (hopefully posted here in the Amplification forum; awaiting moderator approval. It's posted at AA).

I recently set up the Pass Labs X600.5 monos (reviewed, as was the Liquid Pre, for Dagogo.com) and they have been transformed. No longer do they exhibit the thinness I thought was characteristic of them. I now suspect that active preampfification was the culprit in that sound quality. The Liquid Pre and X600.5 is a stellar combo. These are driving the Vapor Audio Nimbus White speakers to great effect. I love the bass presence and quality of the Acoustic Elegance 15" bass driver.

The digital front end is under review, but I will say that I'm doing 32/384. Years ago I said that the ESS Sabre 32 bit chips and architecture would become the standard of digital playback, and they effectively have done so. Not surprising, given the performance.

This is a system I can hear and actually for a while shut down my analytical side, which is very rare. :)

douglas_schroeder

Owner
Papermill, thanks for the complement, which means much given the outstanding rig you have assembled.

Papermill and I have been friends for the better part of the decade and have seen our rigs "grow up" alongside each other. He has a very live sounding room, albeit with excellent absorption elements in the form of rug, soft sided furniture, etc. to complement the delicious décor.

I, on the other hand, have a very damped room, more like a studio. The difference in listening environment is quite striking, and we always remark about it. We have both reached a very high level of performance in two distinct spaces. We both enjoy each other's rig, and admire the sound, which is a great part of this hobby!

Papermill heard the Mac Mini, Clarity Cable Organic USB, a particular DAC under review, the new TEO Liquid Pre, the Wells Audio Innamorata amp, some cables under review, and the Legacy Audio Whisper DSW Clarity Edition (custom edition of the Whisper with 10Ga. Clarity Cable throughout internally). He was in agreement this was the most pristine and involving the Whisper had ever sounded. One of the most striking attributes of adding the Liquid Pre was how dramatically the multiplicity of drivers of the Whisper were tightened in terms of coherency to the point that the speaker lost a great deal of looseness characteristic of line array type speakers.

Now, the most recent build returns to some favorites of the past; Mac Mini via Clarity USB to DAC under review, to Liquid Pre, then Clarity Organic IC to Pass Labs X600.5 Monos, and once again the speaker cables under review, and finally the Vapor Audio Nimbus White. Wow, what a bomb, like a Daisy Cutter has been dropped; quite impressive how much clean output the pair of Acoustic Elegance woofers produce.

The Pass Labs amps are now operating with no weakness; the thinner character I mentioned in the review is gone, and they are holistically improved, very difficult to find fault with this application. The headroom and dynamic power of the X600.5 is, as expected with Pass amps, intoxicating.

I just spoke with Ryan Scott of Vapor yesterday, and told him that it was just as I had said when he delivered the Nimbus White speakers; they would be sounding much better with time. Indeed, they have a much elevated performance level with the Liquid Pre - all the speakers have benefitted thus.

The Liquid Pre does amazing things for rigs, and is one of the simplest, yet most extreme performing components I have laid hands on.

douglas_schroeder

Hi Doug. Yes. The Teo sounds wonderful in your system. Mature refinement! Congrats!

papermill

Owner
I can now discuss my latest joy, the TEO Audio Liquid Pre, which the article exploring is now posted at Dagogo.com.
In case you can't sense it, I'm floored by this passive preamp which uses liquid metal conductors in the wiring. I always enjoy the technology variances in components and systems, and I am quite pleased to have secured such a unique and sensational preamp.

douglas_schroeder

Killer system.

thesaint519

Owner
Jeff, some very good questions. Yes, I know that it seems incredible that a USB cable would have any influence on the sound, but it does. In fact, it has as much impact on the sound for the rig as any other cable. I have, through comparisons of dozens of sets of cables, concluded that any cable has an effect on the system sound, and that any cable can have as much of an impact as any other cable, i.e. USB versus power cord, versus interconnect, etc.

People make their decision on whether they believe it, and act accordingly; those who simply will try are usually rewarded. I am currently using a Clarity Cable Organic USB most often, but I have tried about ten USB cables in my rigs and they all are distinct in sound.

The subwoofers are not front firing, but are Legacy Audio XTREME HD subs which I turned around to have the primary wave launch direct versus off the front wall. They look a lot prettier the other way around, with the face showing, but I prefer the sound this way. You will likely be surprised at how much more is added to a system when using dual subs.

douglas_schroeder

Doug,

Last question.
I noticed in your pictures you have 2 humongous front firing subwoofers.
Who are they?

I've always wAnted to try a dual sub setup.

Jeff

frozentundra

Even more enticement Doug. Hope all is well with you.

roscoeiii

Doug,
I have read thru your entire set of postings.
Wow, over the years you have been thru a lot of stuff!

I'm interested your mac mini and usb and cabling choices.
I'm surprised that a usb cable using digital correction to the data transfers would show,any sonic differences.

What is your choice to date? And do you hear differences?

Digital and analog cables should make a difference, but a usb?

Jeffz

frozentundra

Owner
Roscoeiii, nice to hear from you. There have been many changes in the system since you were here, and the performance has been improved across the board. I don't think you heard my file source, or the rig with speakers repositioned wider.

douglas_schroeder

Very nicely put Doug. So many great sounds that can be put together at this point. To match rooms, budgets, listening preferences and aesthetic tastes.

And your system as I heard it last was a real treat to enjoy.

Hope you are well. Hope to catch up soon once things lighten up down here.

roscoeiii

Owner
Jeff, you're right, the Vapor speakers are quite tempting given their aesthetics, performance level and pricing.

I have gotten the, "So, which do you like the best," question several times from a friend who has heard about half the systems I have set up in the past 5 years or so, and I believe all the speakers. I will tell you the same thing I tell him; my favorite is the one in the rig at the time.

I suspect that's a thoroughly unsatisfying answer, but there are two reasons for it. One is that I expended my budget differently in order to never have to face that question, as I discovered I love the variety of technology and experiencing it as much as the movement toward an ideal expression of one technology. If I had only one speaker I'd likely still be flipping them regularly in an attempt to attain all the sonic qualities they possess.

Secondly, I attempted to select speakers any one of which could be a long term choice, that is, to perform on a level which I would be happy using. As such it is my experience that I often am happiest with the speaker in the rig. If another is put in, shortly I'm elated with that one...

The experience shows several things, including how quickly we adapt to a new sound, how malleable our perceptions are over time, and how many terrific varieties of systems exist, none having it all in terms of a perfect performance.

In a way they are like pets (I think it would be crude to compare them to children), in that an owner of several pets would struggle to simply dismiss all but one. They are unique and pleasing individually. So also the speakers, as they are unique and bring different experiences, which I consider overall a more powerful enjoyment of the hobby than one experience.

The Vapor easily found a place in my system due to its phenomenal coherence and accuracy, and in that respect it is the equal of the King III ESL. Yes, when it's in my system it's my favorite. :)

Finally, I think you have done a commendable job on your rig! I have the Peachtree Nova in my office running with some vintage Eminent Technology LFT-VI speakers, a nice pairing. I also think Thiel did a good job with the SCS-4T, which reminds me somewhat of the Tannoy dual concentric drivers. I would think the combo of the Peachtree and Thiel speakers would sound very good, snappy, fresh, but not irritating. Kudos on putting a good sub with them; good move. You have selected components which I would strongly consider at that price point, so from my perspective you're doing things right. :)

I have a couple of tweak thoughts for your system; if you are interested feel free to contact me via the messaging system here.

douglas_schroeder

Doug,
I've followed the Nimbus white review, really tempting.
I've listened to Vapor audio at Chicago axpona this year.

So, of all the fabulous setups you have.
What is your favorite??????

Jeff

frozentundra

Owner
Radiohead99, these are DACs under review, so I'm not saying much at this point so as to not spill the guts of the findings before the articles are published. If you wish to contact me privately, we can chat.

I will say, however, that I'm finding a lot of ways to elicit great sound from a variety of USB DACs at all price points, from a few hundred dollars to a couple thousand. Also, so far the 32 bit/384kHz up sampling is very impressive treatment of standard CD's. The quality is broadly better than 24/96 high end players I used/reviewed just a few years ago. At this point I would say a move to a USB 32/384 DAC would almost assure a holistically superior sound to 24/96, and perhaps even 24/192 CD players and DACs from five years ago, in general.

In terms of the server, it couldn't get any easier, as I'm using a stock Mac Mini, ripped using iTunes, and on playback switching between iTunes and Amarra (not the latest version as of about a week go - gotta upgrade that!). Even though the server is far from totally tricked out the SQ is excellent. An aftermarket PC on the Mac Mini is recommended, and I'm using one from Audioquest (Note, it's not the typical IEC plug; I think it's a C7 if I'm not mistaken). The performance will get better over time, but even if it plateaued at this point it would be a success. I can hardly imagine having to go back to discs; it would be a step backwards. Due to circumstances I had the transport in the rig for a while this week and I was happy to get back to the Mac and files (Not rank and file!).

One thing which has become evident is that the quality of the DAC is so pervasive that one should audition several. Choose a DAC which results in a performance level which you feel is far, far better than you anticipated possible. If the sound is nice improvement but not radically superior, keep looking.

BTW, also pay careful attention to the USB cable; it's critical to the performance.
You owe it to yourself to try at least 2 or 3.

douglas_schroeder

Doug, Curious about which DAC gave you such a boost in sound quality. Also, if you can please elaborate on your music server solution.

radiohead99

Owner
File playback is progressing quite nicely; SQ levels much higher than I anticipated at this point. I'm comparing a wide variety of USB and DAC components and finding a huge range of performance variance as expected.

I urge those who have been slow to make USB cable changes to do so, as there is a figurative world of quality potential to be discovered, even for those with affordable digital front end.

The elevation of the file playback has lifted the performance of the already impressive Vapor Nimbus White, and I expect similar results with Legacy Whisper, King III, Daedalus, etc.

I'm still only working with PCM converted to AIFF, and had industry members in the room to hear. They are impressed with the result which is largely due to the DACs and USB cabling used, and that's before I even have DSD rolling. I strongly encourage those who have been reluctant to start out with file playback. It has been several months, and I haven't a desire to return to Redbook. That says to me the File playback test is a rousing success! And I'm just getting started. :)

douglas_schroeder

Showing 151 - 175 of 397 posts